Léa Seydoux and Marie Kreutzer were scared to make their new movie, Gentle Monster, a tough drama that plunges into frightening subject matter. That’s also why they took on the challenge. “I think going out of your comfort zone is always good,” says Kreutzer, a 49-year-old Austrian filmmaker. “Especially in the arts.”

“Me too,” says Seydoux, sat next to Kreutzer in the Corinthia Hotel. “I’m nervous.” The 41-year-old French actor, whose CV includes blockbusters like Spectre, Dune: Part Two, and Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol, explains that she’s “unconfident” as a person. When Kreutzer, the chattier of the pair, questions whether Seydoux actually means shyness, the actor quietly responds, “I’m shy, and I cannot say I feel confident all the time.”

After receiving glowing reviews at this year’s Cannes, Gentle Monster was acquired by Netflix (both sip from Netflix mugs during our off-camera conversation) where it will stream after a theatrical release. In the gut-wrenching drama, which was written and directed by Kreutzer, Seydoux stars as an avant-garde pop singer, Lucy Weiss, who performs solo concerts while playing a glass harmonium and multiple pianos at the same time. Did she switch on the confidence for the musical performances?

“Sometimes I was doing those scenes and I was like, ‘My God, what am I doing?’” says Seydoux, laughing. “It’s crazy! Sometimes when you act, to find the right note, you go in directions where you’re like, ‘This is really terrible.’”

“It’s part of the process,” says Kreutzer. She refers to a David Bowie quote that equates creativity to stepping out far enough into water that your feet no longer touch the ground. “You shouldn’t be too comfortable when making art.”

In terms of exploring discomfort, Gentle Monster deserves its own category on the Netflix homepage. In Munich, Lucy resides with her husband, Philip (Laurence Rupp), a frustrated documentarian, and their young son, Johnny. When the police arrive at their home with a search warrant, Lucy learns that Philip has been accused of possessing and distributing child sex abuse imagery through his computer. (A parallel story follows the lead investigator, Elsa, played by Jella Haase, who unwinds with hip-hop.) Lucy immediately unravels at the realisation that she never truly knew the man she married, and, even worse, she becomes paranoid over what happened when he was left alone with their son.

While Gentle Monster strongly implies that Philip is guilty of online crimes, it never reveals the details, if any, of his offline activities. The film thus explores the unknowability of those around us. Even Lucy’s mother (Catherine Deneuve) is oblivious to her daughter’s distress. “Lucy will never know what Philip has done, and she will maybe never know what happened, or didn’t happen, to Johnny,” says Kreutzer. “She also cannot read Johnny’s mind. That’s universal. It’s nothing to do with being good or bad people. We are all our own universe. At the same time, Lucy will trust someone again, because life is about trust.” She adds, with a caveat, “I think.”

Philip repeatedly claims that he’s not a paedophile, at one point insisting that he acquired and sold the illegal images as an easy moneymaker to fund his new movie. Keeping her anguish a secret, Lucy perseveres with her pop concerts, slamming the minor chords on the piano extra hard. When I praise the film for depicting how someone would realistically try to live in denial while her spouse undergoes an investigation, Seydoux intervenes. “I wouldn’t have reacted like her,” she says. “I would have been much more violent.”

Kreutzer made her international breakthrough with 2022’s Corsage, a period drama starring Vicky Krieps as a rule-breaking empress. The character’s husband, in a supporting role, was played by Florian Teichtmeister. At that year’s Cannes, Corsage won an acting award for Krieps; at the London Film Festival, it nabbed the top prize. In January 2023, during the film’s Oscar campaign, it was reported that Teichtmeister had been charged with the possession of child pornography. Corsage remained Austria’s Oscar submission and its international distribution continued as planned.

Kreutzer was already working on Gentle Monster when the Teichtmeister news broke, and had received funding for the project in 2021. In the end credits, she thanks “the haters in 2023”. Why?

“At the time, I thought I couldn’t make Gentle Monster because I thought it would always be connected to him,” says Kreutzer, who never mentions Teichtmeister by name the entire interview. “I was attacked so much for having worked with him, and for not being willing to immediately delete the film from every platform. I thought it was unfair on the hundreds of other people who worked on the film. I was attacked in the press by people I don’t know, but also my colleagues. That was painful. It taught me about resilience. It’s not good to worry too much about what other people think. There are no hard feelings anymore. It made me stronger. That’s why I put it in the credits.”

When you’re an artist, you transform your pain into something beautiful

Did she rewrite Gentle Monster to reflect the Corsage experience? “It didn’t change the script at all, but it did stay with us in an atmospheric way, because the Austrian actors all knew him. Some of us are still trying to wrap our heads around it, because we thought we knew him.”

Teichtmeister comes up again when I question if Philip could possibly be a true artist if he’s such a dishonest person. “The actor I worked with, who then was convicted, he was probably one of the five best actors I’ve ever worked with,” says Kreutzer. “I wouldn’t say just because you’re not honest you can’t be a good artist. It’s funny, some people went the other way, and went, ‘Yeah, he’s a good liar because he’s a good actor.’ But acting is not lying. An artist can also be a bad person. There are many in history!”

“I don’t think an artist needs to be true to themselves,” says Seydoux.

As for Lucy’s concerts in Gentle Monster, she performs radically reworked covers of male-written love ballads, one of them being “Boys Don’t Cry” by The Cure. “That’s an important song about the patriarchy,” says Kreutzer. They ask for my verdict, having noticed me earlier walking into the room with a The Cure cap. I confess that while it doesn’t beat the original, Seydoux is extremely convincing as a pop star. Seydoux quibbles over whether Lucy is a “pop star”, but appreciates the compliment.

How did she inject the darkness of Lucy’s private life into her concerts? “You felt the darkness?” says Seydoux. Yes, I reply. “Well, I have a certain darkness that I try to transform into lightness. Me, as Léa. We’re lucky as artists. I don’t know if I can call myself an artist. But acting was something that helped me overcome a certain struggle to live.”

I tell Seydoux I’ve seen around 25 of her films, and that I’ve always detected a darkness to her performances. “You see that?” she asks. I name the powerful ending of one of her first films, The Beautiful Person, as a specific example. In the last minute of Christophe Honoré’s coming-of-ager, the camera remains fixed on Seydoux’s face as she stares out into the sea.

“It’s true that, as a teenager, I had this mal de vivre,” says Seydoux. “I don’t know how to translate it into English. It’s like a difficulty to live. As a teenager, I was very chaotic, and acting gave me a purpose in life. I wouldn’t say it healed me. I don’t think you can heal from that. But it helped me to transform this very strong melancholy.”

When Lucy performs, she can’t help but pour herself into the songs?

“That’s just how it is when you’re an artist,” says Kreutzer.

“When you’re an artist, you transform your pain into something beautiful,” says Seydoux, who adds, with a comic tone, “All my pain!”

Gentle Monster is in UK cinemas on October 30, and streaming on Netflix from November 18.